OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md markdown
232 lines 16.7 KB
Raw
sha256:8461d44b77376fbf06fa7c3e085d309e3010fd8d5886d63c63e69ce118811ad4 docs: record AFF-b feature-tip SHAs after AFF-b-ISR commit. Human 3 days ago

🆗 Overseer Kit — overseer-kit

Public product name: 🆗 Overseer Kit — overseer-kit is the repo slug only, not the public brand.

Living relay for 🆗 Overseer Kit. Paste the Paste-ready prompt fence into a fresh chat.

NEXT right now = OCI-a (Thinking, new branch/worktree). AFF-b is DONE: BV-r4 pass + ISR pass. Do not continue AFF on this branch.


NEXT SESSION — OCI-a Overseer context isolation freeze

Date: 2026-09-20
Current position: AFF-b DONE → OCI-a Model: Thinking

What just landed

Slice Deliverable
AFF-b-ISR Independent V1–V8 pass. Stamp re-derived sha256:5b8a9aa5…; test_aff_ 101 green (test_output sha256:89b76e1c…). ISR ledger entry a069d8ad…. AFF-b → DONE.
AFF-b Adversarial-freeze honesty gate build complete (BV-r4 + ISR).

THE ONE NEXT STEP — Model: Thinking

Freeze Overseer context isolation on a new dedicated branch/worktree. Do not reuse feat/adversarial-freeze-honesty-gate. Spec-only — no Auto.

ID OCI-a
Branch feat/overseer-context-isolation
Repo overseer-kit
Read first docs/ROADMAP.md (OCI-a row); docs/OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md; docs/OVERSEER-KIT-SPEC.md
Hard stops New branch/worktree · no AFF reuse · no Auto · no consumer sync · no launcher replacement · no Bornfree/VideoFactory edit · no merge to main · no secrets · no live posture flips

Paste-ready prompt — OCI-a

OCI-a — Overseer context isolation freeze (overseer-kit).

Model: Thinking
Repo: overseer-kit
Step: OCI-a
Authority: authoritative
Posture: freeze WHAT/HOW; no Auto implementation

AFF-b is DONE (BV-r4 pass + ISR pass). Start this freeze on a new dedicated
branch/worktree: feat/overseer-context-isolation. Never reuse
feat/adversarial-freeze-honesty-gate.

Read first: docs/ROADMAP.md (OCI-a row); docs/OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md;
docs/OVERSEER-KIT-SPEC.md.

Verified problem (shared kit defect reported from Bornfree / VideoFactory /
Movie Maker):
- stable consumers can execute a live unfinished kit checkout
- inherited cwd can select the wrong repo
- default-lane fallback can inject another lane's NEXT

Freeze:
- stable vs development runtime identity
- consumer-lock compatibility
- repository-bound hooks using explicit -C
- fail-closed lane/window binding
- installer/upgrade rollback
- migration
- seven-tier coverage

Create a frozen: true artifact. Run /freeze-review-loop to pass. Do not start
Auto. Do not append adversarial_freeze in the author session.

Hard stops: No consumer sync · no launcher replacement · no Bornfree /
VideoFactory edit · no merge to main without Tier 3 · no secrets · no live
posture flips · no Auto implementation during Thinking

Shared context (canonical — prepend only when paste fence omits it)

Project 🆗 Overseer Kit — repo-agnostic governance vendoring CLI
Read docs/OVERSEER-KIT-SPEC.md; target phase in docs/ROADMAP.md; this handover
Guardrails No secrets; fail-closed VCS reads; no MuseHub-only baseline features; no Tier-3 automation
Tests Seven tiers per policy/test-tiers.yaml before DONE
Close Update ROADMAP + this handover together; feature branch → PR (no commit/push without consent)
Governance gates §KH1.9 liveok status + governance-sync pending-gate reminders
Muse dev tree ok status --exit-code must show substrate.ok: true, muse_sync.ok: true, and footprint_self_integrity.ok: true before phase DONE
Handover shape (KH1) Every NEXT must include valid Model: from policy/model-labels.yaml and a ### Paste-ready prompt fenced block (H7/H8).

Verified snapshot

Area State
VCS regime muse+git-mirror
GitHub main ebaf51831770c59d3705da85e9d72108908a8bf2
Feature tip (Git) 7a71efa188f22837a696a8b20f83eb0314f9094e
Feature tip (Muse) sha256:b693b50c47c6c0dd0bfcfa3c3dca360f9732b93932e258c34e71080fbc3f47ae
Branch feat/adversarial-freeze-honesty-gate (AFF-b closeout). OCI-a must use a new branch.
Dirty no
Drift D1 drifted vs main until land (expected on feature branch)
AFF-b DONE — BV-r4 pass + ISR pass
AFF-b-ISR pass; verifier cc0054de-21be-4972-ac80-22822646e805; producer d7f82f3d-9259-42cf-bd61-e32193d71c0a; entry a069d8ad…; round 4
AFF-b-BV-r4 pass; verifier 969C4CFD…; evidence f95fe2b5…; test_aff_ 101; test_output sha256:d47e56e52e81c53baf71813ef360beb27bd239ccda222b63c58e87e58047697e
ISR independent test_aff_ 101 passed; test_output sha256:89b76e1cddaabd347f7384d5c9a5a6ac689e118bb51d78bbc4888bb070c4768e
Stamp sha256:5b8a9aa52ee25e9d4824e72b1df4154f8c184cc82bd30703a9b1bb5737eb96c3 (re-derived)
Producer nonce d7f82f3d-9259-42cf-bd61-e32193d71c0a
Muse sync synced

VCS (verified 2026-09-20)

Item Value
Branch feat/adversarial-freeze-honesty-gate
GitHub main ebaf51831770c59d3705da85e9d72108908a8bf2
Dirty no

Hard stops (unchanged)

  • No merge to main without Tier 3 authorization
  • No live capability / posture gate flips without Tier 3 authorization
  • No secrets in commits, adapters, logs, or governance docs
  • Governance sync is mandatory before session end (SD-17)
  • OCI-a: new branch/worktree; no consumer sync; no launcher replacement
  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-ISR → pass; AFF-b → DONE. Independent verifier cc0054de-21be-4972-ac80-22822646e805 ≠ producer d7f82f3d… ≠ BV-r4 969C4CFD…. Re-derived stamp sha256:5b8a9aa5…; V1–V8 clean; test_aff_ 101 (test_output sha256:89b76e1c…). Confirmed Mode B evidence f95fe2b5…. Appended independent_second_review pass round 4, entry a069d8ad…. Mode D → 0. NEXT → OCI-a (Thinking, new branch/worktree). No OCI-a start in this chat. No merge.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r4 → pass; AFF-b remains WIP pending ISR. Independent verifier 969C4CFD-BD3F-43E7-9A51-2CBED235C114 re-derived stamp sha256:5b8a9aa5…; V1–V8 clean; BV3-M1/M2 closed on real render_paste_ready. Seven-tier test_aff_ 101 passed (test_output sha256:d47e56e52e81c53baf71813ef360beb27bd239ccda222b63c58e87e58047697e). Full suite 1480 passed / 15 pre-existing failures; all 15 reproduced on parent ebaf518. Appended verification_evidence pass round 4, entry f95fe2b5…. No ISR, no DONE, no OCI-a, no merge. NEXT → AFF-b-ISR.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-FIX complete; AFF-b remains WIP. Closed BV-r3 BV3-M1–M2 only: adversarial paste pass instruction emits full §AFF.5.2 field set; e2e asserts exact “The kit performs no model call and holds no key.” and the complete pass-field instruction from render_paste_ready. Seven tiers: 101 passed (test_output sha256:9aac8ce3aca73de15887fc9901d4b77d65260b4b7a1e69463a6ab449c0f06ff8). Fixer producer_session_id d7f82f3d-9259-42cf-bd61-e32193d71c0a. No verification_evidence/ISR pass; no DONE; no auto_may_start: true; no merge. NEXT → AFF-b-BV (fresh Thinking chat), then ISR.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r3 → findings; AFF-b remains WIP. Independent verifier A3FD0F5F-AD08-43A0-B262-C5F7E81DDF02. V3 failed: paste pass instruction omitted §AFF.5.2 fields (actor_role, actor_session_id, phase_id, round, reviewer_model); e2e asserted incomplete no-key sentence and did not assert the complete pass-field instruction. No verification_evidence/ISR pass. NEXT → AFF-b-FIX (cited lines only). No DONE. No OCI-a. No merge.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-FIX complete; AFF-b remains WIP. Closed BV-r2 V3 only: §AFF.7.2 paste/render_next_session assertions complete; suggest+absent public ok status --json --exit-code restored (state: absent, exact §AFF.9 warning) with governance-sync retained. Seven tiers: 101 passed (test_output sha256:1bbccffea4cd7370e81c1b59bfefa9a2558239ef89fead6c51c2c530343aa575). Fixer producer_session_id 70B57C08-5CDD-476B-AB5D-ACDDA6FC6B22. No verification_evidence/ISR pass; no DONE; no auto_may_start: true; no merge. NEXT → AFF-b-BV (fresh Thinking chat), then ISR.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r2 → findings; AFF-b remains WIP. Independent verifier re-derived stamp sha256:5b8a9aa5… and reproduced test_aff_ 101 green (test_output sha256:2714f0c2bb53db8b986d4c0503f8a07994be246c2ac83132bd96916c4e470e92). V1/V2/V4–V7 clean for Mode E CLI, require ok status --json --exit-code, governance-sync footer, two-row + Thinking → Auto split, exact type(v) is int / non-blank ts / type(round) is int, no secrets, no auto_may_start: true. V3 failed: paste test still omits several §AFF.7.2 bullets (including render_next_session); suggest+absent public status JSON was dropped. No verification_evidence/ISR pass. NEXT → AFF-b-FIX (cited lines only). No DONE. No OCI-a. No merge.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-FIX complete; AFF-b remains WIP. Repaired exactly BV-r1's public-path coverage gaps. New test_aff_ coverage executes ok status --json --exit-code and governance-sync, Mode-E CLI parser/command wiring, the frozen Thinking → Auto split, and all §AFF.7.2 adversarial paste requirements. The require-mode governance footer now emits its fail-closed message and returns 2. Seven tiers: 101 passed (test_output sha256:17b3cb961cade1cbe06a7ac12efd8d7c11fba2196b71a094c3bd8add7d4a33ac). Full suite by test-directory partition: 1100 passed / 7 pre-existing non-AFF failures; the recorded historical 15-failure baseline was not reproducible in this checkout. Fixer producer_session_id 245D25BC-C44E-4995-9687-03422D0DAB92. No verification_evidence/ISR pass appended; no DONE; no auto_may_start: true; no merge. NEXT → AFF-b-BV (fresh Thinking chat), then ISR.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r1 → findings; AFF-b remains WIP. Independent verifier reproduced seven-tier test_aff_ 100 green (test_output sha256:24051cf4…) and full suite 1479 passed / 15 pre-existing failures. Static/runtime V1–V2 and V4–V8 were clean, including exact type(v) is int, non-blank ts, exact type(round) is int, no secrets, and no auto_may_start: true. V3 failed: helper-only status test did not execute ok status --exit-code or governance-sync; no AFF test exercised Mode-E CLI parsing/command wiring; frozen Thinking → Auto split e2e was absent; and the adversarial NEXT assertion did not prove all §AFF.7.2 requirements. No verification-evidence pass or ISR pass appended. NEXT → AFF-b-FIX. OCI-a context isolation queued after AFF-b DONE on a new branch/worktree; do not bundle it into AFF.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b Auto code complete (not DONE). Built §AFF.2–§AFF.14 / §AFF.16: ledger kind adversarial_freeze, Mode E exit 40, NEXT Trigger A/B + adversarial paste, status/governance-sync adversarial_freeze_gate, twin skill docs/ADVERSARIAL-FREEZE-REVIEW.md + /adversarial-freeze-review, dogfood adversarial_freeze: suggest, shared envelope (type(v) is int, non-blank ts) + type(round) is int on all round-bearing kinds + AFF resolver. test_aff_ 100 green (test_output sha256:b64bac0e…). Producer nonce AED44535-4E5B-4F56-BA72-81B44E222C16. Circular-import fix committed (d8cffc6). No auto_may_start: true. No model dispatch. No merge. NEXT → AFF-b-BV (Thinking, second chat) then ISR (require).

  • 2026-09-20AFF-ADV-r5 → pass; AFF-a DONE. Mechanical restamp sha256:5b8a9aa5…. Reviewer nonce aff-adv-r5-2026-09-20 ≠ author aff-a-author-fix-r4-2026-09-20. NEXT was AFF-b (Auto).

  • 2026-09-20AFF-r7 author repair → pass (AFF-a still WIP). Closed ADV4-M1–M2. Mechanical stamp sha256:04dda1dc….

  • 2026-09-20AFF-ADV-r4 → findings (AFF-a still WIP). ADV4-M1–M2 recorded.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-r6 author repair → pass (AFF-a still WIP). Closed ADV3-M1–M3.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-ADV-r3 → findings (AFF-a stays WIP). ADV3-M1–M3 recorded.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-r5 author repair → pass (AFF-a still WIP). Closed ADV2 findings.

  • Older entries: docs/archive/handover/CHANGE-LOG.md


Handover regeneration rules (SD-3, SD-17)

  1. Docs-first: update docs/ROADMAP.md and durable specs before regenerating this file.
  2. Model label required: every NEXT block and paste prompt includes Model:.
  3. Thinking → Auto split: when NEXT is split, emit {step}a (Thinking) then {step}b (Auto) — never one combined prompt.
  4. Build verification (mandatory): after {step}b, run /build-verification-review before ROADMAP status → DONE.
  5. Closing commit: the session-ending commit bundles code/tests + docs/ROADMAP.md + docs/OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md.
  6. Change log compaction: living change log keeps the newest 15 dated bullets via ok handover-compact --write.

What just landed

Slice Deliverable
AFF-b-ISR pass — V1–V8 clean; ISR entry a069d8ad…; AFF-b → DONE.
AFF-b-BV-r4 pass — V1–V8 clean; evidence f95fe2b5….
AFF-b-FIX Closed BV-r3 BV3-M1/M2; test_aff_ 101.
AFF-b-BV-r3 findings — incomplete §AFF.5.2 pass-field instruction + incomplete no-key e2e.
AFF-b-FIX (BV-r2) Closed BV-r2 V3; test_aff_ 101.
AFF-b-BV-r2 findings — incomplete §AFF.7.2 assertions + dropped suggest+absent status JSON.
AFF-b-BV-r1 findings — public status/governance and Mode-E CLI coverage plus split-flow e2e repair required.
AFF-b Auto Code complete then BV+ISR. §AFF.2–§AFF.14; dogfood suggest; Mode E 40.
AFF-ADV-r5 Different-chat attack review → pass. AFF-a DONE. Stamp sha256:5b8a9aa5….
AFF-a Adversarial-freeze honesty gate freeze pass. Spec-only.
FRV-b F1–F7 DONE — BV pass + ISR pass.

Change log

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-ISR → pass; AFF-b → DONE. Independent test_aff_ 101 (sha256:89b76e1c…); ISR entry a069d8ad…. NEXT → OCI-a (new branch/worktree).

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r4 → pass; AFF-b remains WIP. test_aff_ 101 (sha256:d47e56e…); evidence f95fe2b5…; full-suite 15/15 failures reproduced on parent. NEXT → AFF-b-ISR.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-FIX complete; AFF-b remains WIP. Closed BV-r3 BV3-M1–M2; test_aff_ 101 (sha256:9aac8ce3…). NEXT → AFF-b-BV.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r3 → findings; AFF-b remains WIP. Verifier A3FD0F5F…. V3: incomplete §AFF.5.2 pass fields + incomplete no-key e2e. NEXT → AFF-b-FIX.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-FIX complete; AFF-b remains WIP. Closed BV-r2 V3; test_aff_ 101 (sha256:1bbccffe…). NEXT → AFF-b-BV.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r2 → findings; AFF-b remains WIP. Independent test_aff_ 101 (sha256:2714f0c2…). V3: incomplete §AFF.7.2 assertions + dropped suggest+absent status JSON. NEXT → AFF-b-FIX.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-FIX (BV-r1) repaired public status/governance-sync, Mode-E CLI, and Thinking → Auto split. test_aff_ 101. NEXT was AFF-b-BV.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b-BV-r1 → findings; AFF-b remains WIP. Independent test_aff_ 100; full suite 1479 / 15 pre-existing. NEXT → AFF-b-FIX. OCI-a queued separately after AFF closes.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-b Auto code complete (not DONE). test_aff_ 100; producer AED44535…; NEXT → AFF-b-BV then ISR. No DONE, no merge, no auto_may_start: true.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-ADV-r5 → pass; AFF-a DONE. Mechanical restamp sha256:5b8a9aa5…. NEXT was AFF-b (Auto).

  • 2026-09-20AFF-r7 author repair → pass; AFF-a remains WIP. NEXT was AFF-ADV-r5.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-ADV-r4 → findings; AFF-a remains WIP. ADV4-M1–M2 recorded.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-r6 author repair → pass; AFF-a remains WIP.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-ADV-r3 → findings; AFF-a remains WIP.

  • 2026-09-20AFF-r5 author repair → pass; AFF-a remains WIP.

File History 1 commit
sha256:8461d44b77376fbf06fa7c3e085d309e3010fd8d5886d63c63e69ce118811ad4 docs: record AFF-b feature-tip SHAs after AFF-b-ISR commit. Human 3 days ago