OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md markdown
201 lines 17.7 KB
Raw
sha256:52d8a03eaa91050d3e0d8921986c78b731f7f9f99e7e14b9273193ef9ffc115f chore(governance): sync handover+roadmap to 8358f96 (drift:… Human 11 hours ago

πŸ†— Overseer Kit β€” overseer-kit

Public product name: πŸ†— Overseer Kit β€” overseer-kit is the repo slug only, not the public brand.

Living relay for πŸ†— Overseer Kit. Paste the Paste-ready prompt fence into a fresh chat.


NEXT SESSION β€” Build queue idle (operator pick)

Date: 2026-09-05
Current position: NXP β†’ main DONE (PR #78 @ c921bf1) β†’ queue idle
Model: Operator + Auto

What just landed

Slice Deliverable
NXP β†’ main (land-b) PR #78 merged @ c921bf1. Muse FF sha256:c07f2f34… β†’ muse-bridge β†’ squash. NXP-a freeze + NXP-b build on main.
NXP-b NEXT provenance + board identity (N1–N4). BV-r2 pass + ISR pass (verifier 2869c11a… β‰  producer 3a3eda52…).
N5 unblocked Backlog "Auto-enable session hooks on ok sync" may be freshly frozen when picked (Β§NXP.7 satisfied).

THE ONE NEXT STEP β€” Model: Operator + Auto

Build queue has zero open rows. Pick the next kit slice from the exploration backlog in docs/ROADMAP.md (natural candidate: N5 auto-enable session hooks β€” now unblocked), or author a new Thinking freeze, then regenerate NEXT. Do not re-paste NXP land β€” that row is DONE.

ID queue-idle
Branch feat/governance-sync-* (when docs-only) or feat/<new-slice>
Repo overseer-kit
Read first docs/ROADMAP.md; docs/OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md
Hard stops No merge to main without Tier 3 Β· no secrets Β· no live posture flips Β· no inventing NEXT when ambiguous Β· do not rename consumer boards

Paste-ready prompt β€” queue-idle

queue-idle β€” Build queue idle (overseer-kit).

Model: Operator + Auto
Repo: overseer-kit
Branch: feat/<new-slice-or-governance-sync>
Step: queue-idle
Authority: authoritative

Read first: `docs/ROADMAP.md`; `docs/OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md`.

Deliverables:
- Build queue has zero open rows. Operator picks next slice from the exploration backlog
  (natural candidate: N5 "Auto-enable session hooks on ok sync" β€” Β§NXP.7 unblocked after
  NXP β†’ main PR #78) or authors a new Thinking freeze, then regenerates NEXT.
- Do not re-run NXP land β€” already DONE on main @ c921bf1.

Hard stops: No merge to main without Tier 3 Β· no secrets Β· no live posture flips Β·
 no inventing NEXT when ambiguous Β· do not rename consumer boards

Governance sync: update roadmap + handover on completion.

Shared context (canonical β€” prepend only when paste fence omits it)

Project πŸ†— Overseer Kit β€” repo-agnostic governance vendoring CLI
Read docs/OVERSEER-KIT-SPEC.md; target phase in docs/ROADMAP.md; this handover
Guardrails No secrets; fail-closed VCS reads; no MuseHub-only baseline features; no Tier-3 automation
Tests Seven tiers per policy/test-tiers.yaml before DONE
Close Update ROADMAP + this handover together; feature branch β†’ PR (no commit/push without consent)
Governance gates Β§KH1.9 live β€” ok status + governance-sync pending-gate reminders
Muse dev tree ok status --exit-code must show substrate.ok: true, muse_sync.ok: true, and footprint_self_integrity.ok: true before phase DONE. Hollow substrate β†’ muse init --force .; Muse behind Git (muse_sync: pending) β†’ muse code add -A && muse commit -m "…"; declared-but-absent kit file (footprint_self_integrity: missing) β†’ ok sync (all Tier 1)
Handover shape (KH1) Every NEXT must include valid Model: from policy/model-labels.yaml and a ### Paste-ready prompt fenced block (H7/H8). Never use Operator choice as a Model label.

Verified snapshot

Area State
VCS regime muse+git-mirror
GitHub main 8358f968155a66b2e45bf68237bb324fb2de7601
Canonical anchor sha256:1742cd1969fb4061a1b5b4521b3bca9c6a5aa969a848c496716ad2fe4bfac2e2
Canonical main sha256:1742cd1969fb4061a1b5b4521b3bca9c6a5aa969a848c496716ad2fe4bfac2e2
Branch main
Dirty no
Drift D1=drifted, D2=aligned, D3=aligned

VCS (verified 2026-09-05)

Item Value
Branch main
GitHub main 8358f968155a66b2e45bf68237bb324fb2de7601
Canonical anchor sha256:1742cd1969fb4061a1b5b4521b3bca9c6a5aa969a848c496716ad2fe4bfac2e2 (.muse/git-bridge.toml:last_export.muse_commit_id)
Muse main sha256:1742cd1969fb4061a1b5b4521b3bca9c6a5aa969a848c496716ad2fe4bfac2e2
Dirty no

Hard stops (unchanged)

  • No merge to main without Tier 3 authorization
  • No live capability / posture gate flips without Tier 3 authorization
  • No secrets in commits, adapters, logs, or governance docs
  • Governance sync is mandatory before session end (SD-17)
  • 2026-09-05 β€” NXP β†’ main DONE (land-b). GitHub PR #78 merged @ c921bf1 (NXP-a freeze + NXP-b build). Muse FF sha256:c07f2f34… β†’ muse-bridge β†’ squash. Post-merge sync; N5 backlog unblocked (Β§NXP.7). NEXT β†’ queue-idle.

  • 2026-09-04 β€” NXP-b DONE β€” BV-r2 pass + ISR pass from independent verifier 2869c11a… (β‰  producer 3a3eda52…, who was BV-r1 verifier then NXP-b-FIX producer). V1–V8 over 940c3b4..HEAD, covering both the build commit 410ddc1 and the test fix 6c35b72. BV-r1's findings were re-derived by mutation rather than trusted: 12 targeted mutations run against the NXP tiers, 10 killed. The rewritten Β§NXP.8 e2e row fails (2 β‰  0) when N4 is folded into --exit-code while the pre-fix 410ddc1 row passes under the identical mutation; the rewritten data-integrity row fails on a newline-only fence-body change while the pre-fix row passes (content-byte changes are caught by both) β€” BV1 and BV2 confirmed real, and confirmed genuinely closed. Verified live: twelve-step layout with heading byte-exact on line 1, four Β· U+00B7 separators, stdout minus provenance+blank reproducing pre-NXP nine-step bytes exactly, check-next unconfigured at exit 0 naming bare basename and compliant target, board-naming advisory printing while ok status --exit-code returns 0. Exit precedence 2 > 6 > 35 > 3 > 0, CURRENT_NEXT_HEADING, and extract_paste_fence_body untouched. Β§NXP.8 54 green; suite 1343 pass / 16 pre-existing, failure set identical to parent 940c3b4 in matched worktree environments. Ledger: verification_evidence bv_verdict: pass round 2 (test_output sha256:d4c5e0ae…) + independent_second_review isr_verdict: pass (8e5e49d9…); ok ledger verify β†’ 0; Mode B and Mode D β†’ 0. Two non-blocking observations recorded in NEXT (unasserted check-next --json payload fields; unreachable is_absolute() guard) plus a frozen-spec factual slip in Β§NXP.1 V6. No merge to main β€” NEXT β†’ NXP-land-a (Tier 3).

  • 2026-09-04 β€” NXP-b-FIX applied @ 6c35b72 (producer 3a3eda52… β€” same session as BV-r1, so it cannot verify this). Made the two vacuous Β§NXP.8 rows real: BV1 e2e now uses an initialized fixture that exits 0 on all pre-existing conditions and asserts the N4 advisory fires and exit stays 0; BV2 reconstructs pre-NXP nine-step stdout and asserts byte-for-byte equality after removing exactly the provenance line + blank. BV4 adds Β§NXP.3.6 refusal (exit 2, reason token, message, empty stdout), the absolute_repo_root failure predicate, and Β§NXP.4 failure-shape keys; dropped the discarded first read_at_now(); restored tools/workspace/__init__.py trailing newline. No N1–N4 behavior change. All three original mutations now fail the correct tier. Suite 1343 pass / 16 pre-existing. NEXT β†’ NXP-b-BV-r2 in a fresh chat (ISR producer_session_id: 3a3eda52…).

  • 2026-09-04 β€” NXP-b-BV-r1 β†’ findings (second chat, verifier 3a3eda52…; no ISR appended). V1–V8 against frozen PHASE-NXP-NEXT-PROVENANCE.md Β§NXP.3–§NXP.6: implementation correct β€” verified live, not just green (twelve-step bytes + U+00B7 separators, N2 keys on both JSON shapes, N3 exit 0, N4 advisory present while ok status --exit-code β†’ 0, no secrets/env/subprocess added, board_name_violation reused not forked). Full suite 1340 pass / 16 fail, byte-identical on parent 940c3b4. Findings are test-honesty, not behavior: BV1 Β§NXP.8 e2e exit-code row tautological (tests/e2e/test_print_next_e2e.py:132-134) and BV2 data-integrity fence-body golden newline-insensitive (tests/data_integrity/test_print_next_integrity.py:78-88) β€” both proven vacuous by mutation; BV3 builder producer nonce unrecorded, so actor_session_id β‰  producer_session_id is unassertable; BV4 Β§NXP.3.6 / Β§NXP.4 branches untested. verification_evidence bv_verdict: findings, test_output sha256:a1ea596e…. NEXT β†’ NXP-b-FIX then BV-r2 in a third chat.

  • 2026-09-04 β€” NXP-b code complete on feat/nxp-next-provenance (not DONE). N1 twelve-step provenance + clock seam; N2 JSON identity keys; N3 check-next advisory exit 0; N4 status board-name warn. Β§NXP.8 45 green. Full suite 1340 pass / 16 pre-existing unrelated fails. NEXT β†’ second-chat BV + ISR (require).

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR default β†’ require (operator posture). Absent key / shipped default is now require (was off); kit dogfood require (was warn). Opt out: off or warn. PHASE-ISR operator amend recorded. Closed-loop premise.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR β†’ main + MuseHub solidify DONE. Hub β†’ staging; created aaronrene/overseer-kit; pushed 85 commits; PR #74 @ 84db8c8. NEXT β†’ queue-idle.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” MuseHub-first before ISR merge β€” Gap confirmed: hub localhost:1337 dead; aaronrene/overseer-kit 404 on staging/production. Operator: solidify MuseHub staging then merge PR #74. Handover + paste + MUSE-BRIDGE-WORKFLOW.md retargeted.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR β†’ main land-a β€” Muse FF feat/isr-independent-second-reviewer β†’ main (sha256:f59d4cc6…) β†’ muse-bridge β†’ GitHub PR #74 OPEN/mergeable. Rebased stale muse-mirror onto main before re-export (LT #72/#73 had bypassed mirror). Merge held for MuseHub-first. require_independent_second_reviewer remains kit dogfood warn.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR-b DONE (Auto + second-chat BV pass, ISR-b-BV-r1). V1–V8 against freeze + branch diff; independent_second_review pass (actor c72e9414… β‰  producer 62762b24…); Mode B verification_evidence (test_output sha256:4a82e963…). test_isr_ 48 green. NEXT β†’ ISR β†’ main (land-a). No merge this session.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR-a DONE (Thinking freeze). docs/archive/phases/PHASE-ISR-INDEPENDENT-SECOND-REVIEWER.md β†’ pass (ISR-r4), stamp sha256:e6284150…. Second-chat / separate-verifier gate before Auto DONE; kit records/gates only; no model dispatch; portable CLI+docs primary; seven-tier Β§ISR.11 frozen. No ISR-b Auto code this session. NEXT β†’ ISR-b Auto on feat/isr-independent-second-reviewer.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” consumer-lt-rollout DONE. ok sync LT footprint into Knowtation, Scooling, VideoFactory, the-brain, bornfree-hub, ourware, scooling-lab, scooling-sc-brain. Knowtation/Scooling: session_bookends + honesty warn + hooks; VF/the-brain: bookends + hooks (honesty tip deferred). Knowtation/VF used --only to avoid clobbering living docs / consumer-modified policy. All synced repos footprint_coverage: ok. Deferred: MuseHub (no config.yaml), bornfree/ourware/lab bookends, VF full --force on customized tiers/rules, Knowtation origin:kit living-doc lock hygiene. NEXT β†’ ISR-a (Independent second reviewer Thinking freeze).

  • 2026-09-02 β€” LT β†’ main DONE (land-b). GitHub PR #72 merged @ ff737cc (LT-a freeze + LT-b build). Local main FF; post-merge hygiene; NEXT β†’ consumer-lt-rollout.

  • 2026-09-01 β€” LT-b DONE (Auto build + BV pass, LT-b-BV-r1). Built exactly to frozen docs/archive/phases/PHASE-LT-LOOP-TIGHTENING.md: footprint coverage gate; session_bookends (default off, dogfood enabled + hooks synced); kit honesty warn + active-slice Mode B; ok handover-compact + dogfood compact (88 archived); optional-feature tips on ok status; workspace-root docs; Β§LT.10 34 green. ok sync --force applied; footprint_coverage: ok. No consumer defaults; no tab-reload claim. NEXT β†’ queue-idle.

  • 2026-09-01 β€” LT-a DONE (Thinking freeze). docs/archive/phases/PHASE-LT-LOOP-TIGHTENING.md β†’ pass (LT-r2), stamp sha256:6a5aafb5…. Slices 1–4 frozen. No LT-b Auto code this session. NEXT β†’ LT-b Auto on feat/loop-tightening.

  • 2026-09-01 β€” LT-a drafted (Thinking freeze, review pending). Slices 1–4 in docs/archive/phases/PHASE-LT-LOOP-TIGHTENING.md on feat/loop-tightening. Backlog captured: independent second reviewer, KH2 remask, session-type bookends, auto-enable hooks, host tab reload. No Auto code.

  • Older entries: docs/archive/handover/CHANGE-LOG.md


Handover regeneration rules (SD-3, SD-17)

  1. Docs-first: update docs/ROADMAP.md and durable specs before regenerating this file.
  2. Model label required: every NEXT block and paste prompt includes Model:.
  3. Thinking β†’ Auto split: when NEXT is split, emit {step}a (Thinking) then {step}b (Auto) β€” never one combined prompt.
  4. Build verification (mandatory): after {step}b, run /build-verification-review before ROADMAP status β†’ DONE.
  5. Closing commit: the session-ending commit bundles code/tests + docs/ROADMAP.md + docs/OVERSEER-HANDOVER.md.
  6. Change log compaction: living change log keeps the newest 15 dated bullets. Older bullets move via ok handover-compact --write to docs/archive/handover/CHANGE-LOG.md.

See docs/ROADMAP.md β†’ Model-split handover protocol (SD-3) and governance sync (SD-17).

What just landed

Slice Deliverable
NXP β†’ main PR #78 merged @ c921bf1 (NXP-a + NXP-b). Muse sha256:c07f2f34….
NXP-b NEXT provenance + board identity DONE on main: N1 provenance line, N2 JSON identity keys, N3 check-next advisory at exit 0, N4 ok status board-name warn. BV-r2 pass + ISR pass.
ISR β†’ main PR #74 merged @ 84db8c8 (ISR-a freeze + ISR-b + MuseHub docs).
MuseHub solidify Hub β†’ staging.musehub.ai; public aaronrene/overseer-kit; kit dogfood matches Knowtation/Scooling hub posture.
PR #73 docs: LT land-b closeout + consumer rollout NEXT (merged 2026-09-02)

Change log

  • 2026-09-05 β€” governance-sync: drift (D1=drifted, D2=aligned, D3=aligned) @ 8358f96; realign: D2 aligned β€” skip realign; next_regen=human_authorship_required:zero_open_rows

  • 2026-09-05 β€” governance-sync: drift (D1=drifted, D2=aligned, D3=aligned) @ bdf1f20; realign: D2 aligned β€” skip realign; next_regen=human_authorship_required:zero_open_rows

  • 2026-09-05 β€” governance-sync: drift (D1=drifted, D2=aligned, D3=aligned) @ 1e1582c; realign: D2 aligned β€” skip realign; next_regen=human_authorship_required:zero_open_rows

  • 2026-09-05 β€” NXP β†’ main DONE (land-b). PR #78 @ c921bf1. NEXT β†’ queue-idle (N5 backlog unblocked).

  • 2026-09-04 β€” NXP-b DONE. BV-r2 pass + ISR pass (verifier 2869c11a… β‰  producer 3a3eda52…). BV-r1's two findings re-derived by mutation and confirmed closed. NEXT β†’ NXP-land-a (Tier 3, no merge yet).

  • 2026-09-04 β€” NXP-b-BV-r1 β†’ findings (second chat). Implementation matches Β§NXP.3–§NXP.6; two Β§NXP.8 matrix rows asserted vacuously (mutation-proven). No ISR, no DONE. NEXT β†’ NXP-b-FIX.

  • 2026-09-04 β€” governance-sync: drift (D1=drifted, D2=aligned, D3=aligned) @ ce16f9b; realign: D2 aligned β€” skip realign; next_regen=human_authorship_required:zero_open_rows

  • 2026-09-02 β€” governance-sync: drift (D1=drifted, D2=aligned, D3=aligned) @ fc2ecb0; realign: D2 aligned β€” skip realign; next_regen=human_authorship_required:zero_open_rows

  • 2026-09-02 β€” governance-sync: drift (D1=drifted, D2=aligned, D3=aligned) @ 945d034; realign: D2 aligned β€” skip realign; next_regen=human_authorship_required:zero_open_rows

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR β†’ main + MuseHub solidify DONE. PR #74 @ 84db8c8; staging hub hosts kit. NEXT β†’ queue-idle.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” MuseHub solidify DONE β€” connected staging.musehub.ai; created public aaronrene/overseer-kit; first push 85 commits.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR-b DONE (Auto + BV pass, ISR-b-BV-r1).

  • 2026-09-02 β€” ISR-a DONE (Thinking freeze). PHASE-ISR β†’ pass (ISR-r4).

  • 2026-09-02 β€” consumer-lt-rollout DONE. LT synced to live consumers.

  • 2026-09-02 β€” LT β†’ main DONE (land-b). PR #72 @ ff737cc.

File History 1 commit
sha256:52d8a03eaa91050d3e0d8921986c78b731f7f9f99e7e14b9273193ef9ffc115f chore(governance): sync handover+roadmap to 8358f96 (drift:… Human 11 hours ago