2026-08-27-rhf-b-kn0-bv-round1-pass.md
markdown
sha256:4215cecbbabf5591b1ff69053cc938b4b6c800f0d487be40618c1d4254d8b67b
security: npm audit fix pre-bridge 2026-09-05
Human
1 day ago
Build verification — RHF-b-KN0 round 1
Verdict: pass
Frozen spec: ~/scooling/docs/reviews/2026-08-27-retail-helper-finish.md (§B1 compatibility deploy, §B5)
Branch: feat/retail-helper-finish-b-kn0
Reviewer mode: independent verifier (thinking-high posture)
Scope checked
KN0 compatibility slice only — no KN1 renewal/cutover, candidate/marker creation, consent, grant mint in production, deploy, or env flip.
Findings
| ID | Sev | path:line | Claim vs reality |
|---|---|---|---|
| — | — | — | No actionable gaps |
Checklist
| # | Check | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| V1 | Deliverables exist | lib/agent/trusted-external-provider-catalog.mjs; lib/agent/delegation-authority-compat.mjs; wired in lib/agent/delegation.mjs, hub/bridge/delegation-routes.mjs, hub/bridge/delegation-blob-store.mjs; test/rhf-b-kn0-compatibility.test.mjs |
| V2 | Bridge generic mint rejects human session before vault/mint | hub/bridge/delegation-routes.mjs — humanSessionTokenFromReq returns 403 DELEGATION_HELPER_ACTOR_DENIED before vaultContext / handleDelegationGrantMintRequest |
| V2 | Catalog agent_codex_retail exact |
trusted-external-provider-catalog.mjs:13-27 matches freeze §B1 JSON literals |
| V2 | Marker-aware reads fail closed | delegation-authority-compat.mjs — absent marker → legacy; invalid/missing envelope → DELEGATION_AUTHORITY_UNAVAILABLE; resolveDelegationReadContext surfaces 503 in handlers |
| V2 | Reserved id cannot shadow catalog | getAgentIdentity checks catalog first; propose/precheck return 409 AGENT_IDENTITY_RESERVED |
| V3 | Seven-tier tests | test/rhf-b-kn0-compatibility.test.mjs 17/17; legacy comparator legacyBridgeGrantMintWouldAcceptSession vs new gate |
| V4 | No KN1 scope | No renew-personal, validate, helper-access, DelegationAuthorityStore mutations, marker/candidate writers |
| V5 | No silent requirement deletion | All six operator-required items present |
| V6 | Governance | ROADMAP + OVERSEER-HANDOVER updated together this session |
| V7 | No secrets | Catalog is public metadata; no bearer/JWT persistence added |
Evidence
| type | sha256 | ref | notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| test_output | 1955887c90bc180f53e8b96efca9d3d38525e9ae8f7c3564ba2fce96143a568d |
test/rhf-b-kn0-compatibility.test.mjs 17/17 |
KN0 suite |
| test_output | (combined) | KN0 + SEC-KN-4/5 + delegation-hosted-proposal-l1b | 79/79 green in session |
Verdict rationale
Implementation matches the passed freeze’s KN0 compatibility deploy: session-bound generic Bridge mint is denied before catalog/store resolution; immutable reserved Codex retail catalog resolves first and cannot be shadowed; marker-aware reader follows validated active marker else legacy with 503 fail-closed on mismatch. Tests include explicit legacy comparator and all seven tiers.
File History
1 commit
sha256:4215cecbbabf5591b1ff69053cc938b4b6c800f0d487be40618c1d4254d8b67b
security: npm audit fix pre-bridge 2026-09-05
Human
1 day ago