Build verification — FLOW-WRITE-LIVE-KN-b round 1
Verdict: pass
Frozen spec: ~/scooling/docs/FLOW-WRITE-LIVE-FREEZE.md (frozen: true,
review_stamp.verdict: pass, digest sha256:24c31c41…)
Diff scope: Knowtation Muse branch feat/flow-write-live-kn-b — Flow
external_ref propose validation, T5 Flow fingerprint admission, seven-tier tests,
PROPOSAL-LIFECYCLE + governance.
Findings
| ID |
Sev |
path:line |
Claim vs reality |
| — |
— |
— |
No blocking findings |
Evidence
| type |
sha256 |
ref |
notes |
| test_output |
b64ed99cd6e71afb4d5fae0ef905d4b428f16877fdf6cf0505abf7500b87dcbc |
node --test test/flow-write-live-kn-b.test.mjs |
11/11 pass (7 suites / §FWL.7) |
| test_file |
880a4720a43e9a83a2771f66efa2b1a1b135840056d09795902f0ce35867e3b7 |
test/flow-write-live-kn-b.test.mjs |
Seven-tier source |
Checklist
| # |
Check |
Evidence |
| V1 |
§FWL.8 KN-b deliverables present |
resolveFlowProposeExternalRef in lib/flow/flow-authoring.mjs; matchesScoolingFlowFingerprint + T5 widen in lib/hub-proposal-personal-self-apply.mjs; SCOOLING_FLOW_EXTERNAL_REF_RE in lib/scooling-external-ref.mjs; PROPOSAL-LIFECYCLE Flow row |
| V2 |
Fingerprint matches §FWL.4.1 |
source flow; kind exact {new,edit,import} with no missing-kind default; path ^meta/flows/…\.md$; ref ^scooling\.flow:…{1,128}$; personal scope; session binding via existing seam gates |
| V3 |
§FWL.7 seven-tier |
unit/integration/e2e/stress/data-integrity/performance/security in test/flow-write-live-kn-b.test.mjs — 11/11 |
| V4 |
No scope creep |
No Scooling posture flip (FLOW_AUTHORING_WRITES_AUTHORIZED still false); no prod FLOW_AUTHORING_WRITES; capture/run/Delegation unchanged |
| V5 |
Spec requirements retained |
Capture / Delegation / project/org / wrong-ref / missing kind still refuse |
| V6 |
Governance truthful |
ROADMAP/HANDOVER updated with BV pass + NEXT = SC-b |
| V7 |
Security |
Injection chars fail regex; P4 delegation refused; no secrets in envelopes |
| V8 |
Claims ↔ tests |
Diff implements §FWL.4; tests exercise real propose + admission paths |
Honest summary
Knowtation Wave 1 Flow authoring admission is implemented on
feat/flow-write-live-kn-b: propose accepts optional scooling.flow: refs for
new/edit/import (malformed → 400; absent → propose ok, not admitted; import
lineage no longer substitutes), personal self-apply T5 admits §FWL.4.1 fingerprints
only, and seven-tier tests are green. No production env or Scooling posture change.
NEXT = FLOW-WRITE-LIVE-SC-b on Scooling (posture still false).