actor_role: verifier

isr_verdict: pass

notes: ISR-b-BV-r1 second chat V1-V8 pass; actor_session_id is verifier chat; producer_session_id is builder chat nonce

phase_id: ISR-b Independent second reviewer build


notes: 48 passed (seven-tier test_isr_)

ref: pytest tests/**/test_isr_*.py -q

bv_verdict: pass


notes: 51 passed (seven-tier NXP.8 + ONS layout updates); full suite 1340 passed / 16 pre-existing fails identical on parent 940c3b4

ref: pytest tests/{unit,integration,e2e,stress,data_integrity,performance,security} -k print_next/nxp/workspace -q

bv_verdict: findings

notes: NXP-b-BV-r1 second chat, V1-V8: implementation matches NXP.3-NXP.6 (verified live). findings = 2 frozen NXP.8 matrix rows not actually asserted (e2e exit-code tautology, data-integrity newline-insensitive golden), proven by mutation; plus builder producer_session nonce unrecorded so ISR cannot be appended truthfully. No DONE.

phase_id: NXP-b NEXT provenance build


notes: Seven-tier NXP.8 subset 54 passed. Full-suite failure set at b86291c is identical to parent 940c3b4 when both are run in matched git-worktree environments (43 = 43, zero new, zero fixed); the 16 seen in the primary checkout are a strict subset.

ref: pytest -p no:randomly <9 NXP tier files> (54 passed) + pytest -q full suite (1343 passed / 16 pre-existing failures) @ b86291c

notes: NXP-b-BV-r2 independent V1-V8 over 940c3b4..HEAD (build commit 410ddc1 + test fix 6c35b72). BV-r1 findings re-derived from scratch, not taken on trust: 12 targeted mutations run against the NXP tiers, 10 killed. Confirmed by mutation that the rewritten e2e row fails when N4 is folded into --exit-code (exit 2 != 0) while the pre-fix 410ddc1 row passes under the same mutation, and that the rewritten data-integrity row fails on a newline-only fence-body change while the pre-fix row passes; a content-byte change is caught by both. Live on this repo: twelve-step layout with heading byte-exact on line 1, 4x U+00B7 separators, stdout minus provenance+blank reproduces pre-NXP nine-step bytes exactly, check-next unconfigured exits 0 with named bare basename and compliant target, status board-naming advisory fires while status --exit-code returns 0. Exit precedence 2>6>35>3>0, CURRENT_NEXT_HEADING, and extract_paste_fence_body untouched by the diff. Two surviving mutations are non-blocking and outside the frozen NXP.8 matrix: the workspace check-next --json payload exit_code/ok fields are unasserted, and the absolute_repo_root is_absolute() guard is an unreachable defensive branch (its spec-required OSError refusal path is tested).


notes: Independent second reviewer for NXP-b. This chat is not 3a3eda52-b099-4717-8067-c6c10a2362c0, which acted as BV-r1 verifier and then as NXP-b-FIX producer at 6c35b72 and therefore cannot verify its own test fixes. BV-r1's findings were re-derived by mutation rather than accepted on trust; see the round 2 verification_evidence entry. No ISR waiver, no producer-session reuse, no main merge, no hook changes, no consumer board renames, no assert weakened.